—— Restoration case study · Sumner Hill, Jamaica Plain

12 Everett Street: a Sumner Hill Victorian, reborn as three condominiums.

A historic exterior, restored. Soft-modern homes inside. We sold all three, found the buyers for two of them, and resold the first in 2026 for more than it sold for new.

Talk to us about your project →

3 of 3

Condos sold

$4.08M

Total sales

Avg. days to offer

2 of 3

Buyers found by Arborview

—— The project

Webb Place, in historic Sumner Hill.

Set back from the street in a park-like setting, 12 Everett Street paired a restored historic Victorian exterior with expansive, soft-modern interiors: three 3-bedroom, 3-bath condominiums with garages, a cobblestone-style driveway and large private decks, patio or yard. Fully electric, with efficient heat pumps and serious sound-reducing construction between homes, and steps from the Green Street Orange Line, Centre Street, the Arboretum and Jamaica Pond.

Twilight exterior, 12 Everett Street, Jamaica Plain — Twilight exterior

—— How we sold it

A big project, told as one story.

Three homes at this level needed buyers to understand the whole building, not just a unit. We gave 12 Everett its own property website, a print brochure with full spec sheets and floor plans for every unit, twilight and aerial photography, and a launch that put the location and craftsmanship first.

Aerial over Sumner Hill, 12 Everett Street, Jamaica Plain — Aerial over Sumner Hill

Kitchen with book-matched walnut island, 12 Everett Street, Jamaica Plain — Kitchen with book-matched walnut island

Open living and dining, 12 Everett Street, Jamaica Plain — Open living and dining

—— The results

All three sold, for $4.08 million.

Home	Size	List price	Sold for	To offer	Closed	Buyer’s agent
Unit 1	3 bd / 3 ba · 2,123 sq ft	$1,299,999	$1,286,999	5 days	Dec 2023	Arborview
Unit 2	3 bd / 3 ba · 1,949 sq ft	$1,399,999	$1,385,000	8 days	Nov 2023	Arborview
Unit 3	3 bd / 3 ba · 1,936 sq ft	$1,399,999	$1,410,000	38 days	Dec 2023	Another brokerage

The 2026 resale

Unit 1, sold again, for more.

In 2026 we listed Unit 1 again at $1,350,000 and it sold for $1,372,500, above asking with an offer in 7 days, about 6.6% more than its 2023 price.

—— Built to last

What buyers paid for.

Restored historic Victorian exteriorSoft-modern interiors3 bed / 3 full bath homes~1,940–2,120 sq ftGarages, EV-readyCobblestone-style drivewayPrivate decks, patio & yardFully electric, high-efficiency heat pumpsCentral airSound-reducing constructionPella STC windows4″ white oak floorsFisher & Paykel appliancesBook-matched walnut islandNeolith & quartzite countersFully sprinklered

—— Jamaica Plain’s #1 team, 2011–2026

We sell the best of Jamaica Plain.

Historic restorations like 12 Everett, ground-up new construction like 61 Montebello, condos and multi-families across JP.

61 Montebello case study → Working with developers

—— Questions we hear

Condos in Sumner Hill

What do new condos sell for in Sumner Hill, Jamaica Plain?

At 12 Everett Street, three 3-bedroom, 3-bath condominiums of about 1,940 to 2,120 square feet sold for $1,286,999 to $1,410,000 in late 2023, and Unit 1 resold for $1,372,500 in June 2026. Across all four sales the average was about $673 per square foot.

Do restored historic condos in Jamaica Plain hold their value?

At 12 Everett Street, Unit 1 sold for $1,286,999 in December 2023 and resold for $1,372,500 in June 2026, about 6.6% higher, above its asking price with an offer in 7 days.

Who sold the 12 Everett Street condos in Jamaica Plain?

The Christian Iantosca Team at Arborview Realty listed and sold all three condominiums in 2023, representing the buyers on two of the three, and listed the 2026 resale of Unit 1.

Sales data from MLS Property Information Network. Square footage from the project’s floor plans and is approximate.